Service Profit Chain

The Frontline Manager Makes the World go Around

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Despite the fact that we read stories that companies such as Zappos and others are abolishing the role of middle management, the reality out there is that the vast majority of companies rely heavily on middle managers to keep the wheels moving.

So, unless you have embarked on the experiment of abolishing middle managers, there is a high likelihood that you recognize that your frontline managers are crucial to your business.

Take one metric. Staff turnover.

A controllable cost that also has a high impact on your customer loyalty and satisfaction. It is widely recognized that employee turnover is linked to the management style of the immediate supervisor.

Or, change management.

Whatever customer satisfaction strategy and tactics you are developing – the effort is wasted if your frontline is not implementing according to that plan.

The Frontline Manager is the Linchpin

But, how much attention are you giving the growth and development of those frontline managers?
If you are like most of the companies recently surveyed by HBR, not much.

What that same survey shows is that, paradoxically, the same companies that say the frontline manager is a linchpin in the organization also say that the same frontline managers need to develop a number of crucial skills, including organizational savvy, leadership, and talent development.

But they recognize that not much is being done in the company to actually develop those people – go figure.

The reality out there – still according to the HBR survey – is that most development for this level of management tends to be ad hoc, sporadic, or just too brief to actually make a difference.

In general, it seems that leadership development follows the trickle-down model. Most gets invested at the top; and if there are resources left, they are spent on the frontline managers – sometimes.

So, once again, we have a classic knowing – doing gap. The problem is recognized – but somehow nothing gets done.
I wonder why.
Let’s just recap why frontline leadership is crucial to your service organization. We live in a world of Hypercompetition. Customers are flooded with offers and messages. In every imaginable category, supply outstrips demand.

So, if you are not just going to live a mediocre existence trying to survive, you need to stand out and be, if not the absolute best, then at least among the best.

Your aim is customer loyalty. If you can get that right, you will drive profits and growth as a result. This is the basic learning from the research done that led to The Service Profit Chain.

The best starting point for developing your frontline managers is to introduce them to the Service Profit Chain framework.

If you would like a refresher course on the mechanics of the Service Profit Chain and how employee engagement ultimately leads to profit and growth, check out my free video course here:

A Managers Guide to a Dream Team

April 14, 2022By Mike Hohnen

The Service Profit Chain is a well-documented concept.

Since the original research was published in 1989, hundreds of articles have promoted the original findings which essentially boil down to the fact that happy employees create happy customers – and the happier the customers you have, the more money you make –
Yes, I know that was a very simplified version.

What not so many people talk about, or even document, is that this concept of ‘happy employees’ is not so much a question of employee satisfaction but, to a much higher degree, a question of employee engagement.
So, what are the steps to producing a high level of engagement on a service team?
According to the original research in The Service Profit Chain, there 8 steps in a self-reinforcing cycle called the dream team cycle.
Look closely and you will recognize that this is exactly what the best high profile service companies do:

The Right Team
Careful selection of new recruits. Hire for attitude. Train for skills.Coach for performance and that includes dealing with the bad apples.
Continuous Improvement
Best in class training and development at all levels in the organization. Continuous improvement is considered one of the great benefits of the job. “In this job, I grow”…
Great Support Systems
Service is not just something the frontline does for our customers. Service is our culture. Employees and managers who do not have customer contact service the employees that do. (Our IT department is not the IT-Police – it is an internal service department that supports the frontline in getting the job done.)
Empowerment
The best service employees take pride in solving the problem on the spot. So the freedom to act is hugely motivating. Southwest Airlines famously tells its employees, ”You may do anything you are not uncomfortable doing to solve a passengers problem.”
Clear Expectations
In the same way that anyone who has made it to a great sports team knows what is expected of them, employees in the best service organizations also know what is expected of them. It is part of their motivation to be part of a team that is not afraid to set the bar high.
Appropriate Rewards and Recognition
Focusing on what works, celebrating success, and acknowledging each others contributions makes work meaningful.
High Levels of Satisfaction and Engagement
As a result of Steps 1-6, we generate not just higher levels of satisfaction, but also real engagement – Service work becomes fun and meaningful.

Employees Recommend New Employees
When we need to recruit new team members, our best employees recommend friends and previous colleagues from other organizations because these are the people they would like to work with. Gradually we become the preferred employer in our region – which means we get the pick of the crop.

And that takes us back to Step 1 – The Right Team.
Done consistently this 8-step cycle become a self-reinforcing process that propels our service delivery capacity to higher and higher levels – and we all know what that does for our customer satisfaction and loyalty.

——

Building a great service business begins with understanding the Service Profit Chain framework. In my view, that is the foundation. Check out my free introduction here

The Asymmetric Nature of Services

April 21, 2016By Mike Hohnen

In my previous blogposts, we started looking at this whole concept that we have labeled “The Experience Economy” and why the shift towards a service-dominant logic is raising the bar for everyone involved in service.

So, if we can agree that there is a shift from focusing on goods to focusing on needs, we need to spend some time understanding the concept of needs as seen from the consumer’s perspective.

Many hotels, restaurants, or other traditional service providers forget that they are in the needs business and fall in love with their own products. They mistakenly think that it is the product the consumer is actually interested in and do not understand that the product is just a translation of their needs into something more tangible.

Loving the product and missing the need is also what happens every time a company or industry is disrupted. The needs shift or someone sees a totally different way to fulfil those needs – and titans of industry get washed away. Kodak never believed for one moment that we would ever drop Kodachrome and replace it with pixels.

Services are Asymmetric

So, when we look at the nature of services, it is important to remember that there is this phenomenon of asymmetry – what you sell and what the consumer buys are often two very different things. If you are an airline, you will have a tendency to think of your product as Seat 7A on Flight AB1234. That is what you have sold to that passenger. But the passenger doesn’t think of it that way. What they have purchased is transportation from A to B. That is the need they have.

If you take the restaurant industry, you don’t go to a fine dining restaurant because you are hungry. The restaurant may see itself as providing food and drink…that is its product. But, you are presumably there for something completely different. Something that has to do with atmosphere, occasion, or whatever.

In the hotel industry, they see themselves as providing you a room with certain specifications. But in many cases, you are not in that market for that product specification. You are in the market for a good night’s sleep…that is your need. If the ventilator on the ice machine rattles all night and prevents you from sleeping, then all the beautiful treats and frills in your room are not going to help one iota – you will hate the experience.

So, in that way, traditional service providers also need to make sure that they don’t fall into the trap of seeing themselves as product providers fixated by their own product specifications, to the extent that they forget about what the need is that they are supposed to fulfill.

Now, the problem this surfaces is that needs are deeply personal, subjective, and situational. So, when the travel industry talks about pax – we have 50 pax next week and then 200 pax on that flight – or the restaurant industry talks about covers – we will be doing 145 covers for dinner and then 85 covers for lunch – it is an insult to the individuality of their customers.

What pax and covers implies is that they are all the same – a flock of sheep that all need a standard shearing.

In the next blog post, we will take a closer look at how we can get better at understanding what needs are all about and maybe, more importantly, how to better get a grip on the fact that different people have different needs

– welcome to the age of mass-customization.

The Big Shift – Products to Services

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

This is the second post in a series on the new service economy. You will find the first post here.

Before we start dissecting what it actually means to create fantastic experiences and great services, I think it’s useful to take a step back and try to understand the big picture on how the world that we are operating in, as service providers, is changing quite dramatically.

There is a big shift taking place world-wide, and it is a shift that moves away from a focus on producing stuff to delivering services. It is also described as the move from a goods-dominate logic towards a service-dominate logic.

What that basically means is that for thousands of years, we have been used to creating value by taking something, adding to it, and then exchanging it with somebody else in return for their money. The focus has been on the functionality, the specifications, and the quality of the actual product. The better the specifications, the more money we have been able to obtain for that product.

What is happening now is a gradual shift away from a focus on products towards a focus on needs.

Recently I realized I needed go buy a new power drill in order to put a cupboard up on the wall. My old drill doesn’t work very well anymore because it has been lying at the bottom of my cupboard for the past ten years without being used. So, I decide to go get a better drill. But, do I really have a need for a drill? My next drill is probably also going to lie in the cupboard for a few years before I use it again. What I really need is two holes in a very hard wall. If somebody could provide those holes for me in a faster, easier way that would require less effort, less resources, or less trouble for me, I would grab that opportunity immediately.

If you are in the service industry, you may not have paid attention to this because, in the service industry, one has been, in a certain respect, in the service-dominate logic forever. But what is happening is that a lot of traditional manufacturers and producers are also moving away from their traditional goods-dominate logic, and instead they are thinking about how they can make that shift from product specifications to needs fulfillment.

In a service-dominate logic, the value is not created by a transfer of ownership, value is created in use. When I use your product or service, it brings value to me; and the minute I am not using it, it no longer provides value for me.

A great example of this is Mercedes-Benz, their smart car, and the service they have now created in more than 30 cities called “Car2Go”. You can grab the car off of the street with just your membership card and drive from A to B and then leave the car. Most of us living in big cities don’t need to own a car – in fact, it is a downright nuisance. What we do need is flexible transportation at our fingertips. There are lots of other examples of this new trend if you start looking around.

Why do I think this is important?

Because, what this means for the traditional part of the service industry is that more and more consumers are going to experience higher and higher levels of service. Great service is going to be the new normal.

And, that is going to raise the bar…the level of service expected across the board…is my prediction.

In my next blog post, we will examine the concept of value.

Customer Centric : they get it – Virgin Hotels

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

In my previous post, I tried to illustrate how some hotels (and other service businesses) truly understand what it means to be customer centric and then all the others who really just don’t get it.

Two days after posting that I came across the following video from Virgin – who is now entering the hotel industry.

This is interesting because Virgin has always had a strategy of moving into industries where most of the players just don’t get it… Airlines, trains, banks, phone providers, and now hotels. What it means is that Virgin sees an opportunity to do it much better…there is room for improvement… Check out their website

Virgin Hotels – ‘Brilliant’ Not To Scale New York. from Not To Scale on Vimeo.

We make love and steal hearts. We’re passionate about creating brilliant experiences that make peoples’ lives better. And there’s nothing more honorable than that.

A culture of doing stuff

May 12, 2014By Mike Hohnen

“Only the leader can set the tone of the dialogue in the organization. Dialogue is the core of culture and the basic unit of work. How people talk to each other absolutely determines how well the organization will function. Is the dialogue stilted,politicized, fragmented and but covering ? Or is it candid and reality-based, raising the right questions, debating them, and finding realistic solutions. If it’s the former as it is in all too many companies, reality will never come to the surface.

You cannot have an execution culture without robust dialogue, one that brings reality to the surface through openness, candor and informality.”

Execution, the Discipline of Getting Things Done, Larry Bossidy (CEO Honeywell Int’l) and Ram Charan with Charles Buck.

Building the emotional connection

April 14, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Here is a great example of a brand making the emotional connection

In my view a brand is a product that you have feelings for – it becomes a brand the moment you ‘care’ about it in some way.

That is also the reason why we spend so much time talking about the importance of generating customer loyalty when we work with implementation of the Service Profit Chain.
Emotions drive loyalty.

Your ‘product’ becomes a brand in your guests head as a result of the emotional connection that your staff makes with the guest.

The first step in brand building is therefore making that connection ( it is not advertising spend) – then you can always reinforce that with clever advertising as it is done here – but it starts with positive moments of truth

Customer Loyalty – the magic formula

April 21, 2016By Mike Hohnen

Most of us experience a market situation that can best be described as hyper-competition. Supply out strips demand in virtually any category you can think of.

When that plays out advertising becomes less and less useful because there is already so much of it that few people, if any pay attention to it.

So the name of the game is customer loyalty – trying to draw customers closer to us in such a way that they are less tempted to switch to the competitions latest bargain offer.

Many companies use a variety of sophisticated marketing tools and tricks to do this from simple punchcards that give you your 10Th coffee for free to more elaborate loyalty clubs like what many Air Lines have developed.

But I don’t think that bribing customers to come back is what really counts. It may produce some form of customer renetion but there is no emotional loyalty.

What is loyalty then if not retention or what is the difference you may ask?

Well, there are two reasons we need customer loyalty. One is the obvious, that it is much cheaper to sell to an existing customer than it is to acquire a new one.That is the Customer retention part.

But more importantly loyal customers tell their friends – in fact the more loyal they are the more they talk about it – and that is what makes the all important difference between mechanicaly loyal and emotionally loyal.

When you have positive emotional feelings about a product or a brand you become an ambassador or what Fred Reicheld calls a ‘promoter’.(Here is a quick overview of the Net Promotor Score system)

Obviously in order for customers to become loyal they must first of all be satisfied to some degree. Customer satisfaction is the prerequisite for customer loyalty. But how much customer satisfaction does it take to create lasting loyalty?

From deeply dissatisfied to relatively happy, nothing much happens. Then, as satisfaction becomes more than just satisfaction and turns into enthusiasm, loyalty increases sharply.

But notice that when we deliver the right service/product at the right price, at the right time, and to the agreed-upon specifications, we score a 3 or possibly a 3.5 if we are lucky.

“Hey! But that is not fair,” you might be thinking, “we are doing everything perfectly and just as agreed, and all we get is lukewarm feedback!”

Doing everything perfectly and as agreed upon is exactly the problem. When clients read your marketing material or listen to your sales pitch, they learn that you will do this, this, and this for them at this price and on such and such terms.

So, who will be impressed when you actually deliver on what you said you would deliver?

You are performing exactly as expected. If you do less, they will be annoyed. If you do more, they will be en route to enthusiasm. If what you do far exceeds their expectations, they will be ecstatic.

But what can we do more than delivering everything we said we would?

We can establish an emotional connection. And because so few companies get it, it is still unexpected. When we touch our customers emotionally we exceed their wildest expectations.

Just think of a wonderful service experience you have had at some point. What made it exceptional? The mechanical stuff or was it because some one touched you at an emotional level some how?

Nine times out of ten you will find that what creates enthusiasm and loyalty is an emotional connection.

So forget the punch cards and the bonus points – what you need to work on is your team.

It is the attitude and loyalty of your team to your business that drives true customer loyalty. ( see my previous post on Employee loyalty here)

Loyal employees create loyal customers – that is the magic formula and that is also at the heart of the Service Profit Chain