customer experience

If it is all about loyalty, does satisfaction matter?

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Consistency

It is true that in the Service Profit Chain framework, there is a huge emphasis on establishing loyalty; loyalty is the key driver of profit and growth.

Before we can even hope to establish a relationship that will lead to loyalty, we must ensure that we have a firm grip on the basics and that we can deliver on our promise every time. The keyword here is consistency, the key driver of basic satisfaction.

Consistency or lack of consistency is also one of my pet grievances. Consistency is the flip side of reliability. If as a customer I had a great experience last week, you as a service provider have implicitly promised me that I will have the same experience when I return next week.

If not, you are not only unreliable in my eyes, but you are also performing below my expectations, and we all know that meeting expectations is the first key to customer satisfaction.

This is a balancing act because, on the one hand, we would like to see creativity and initiative on the part of our teams, but on the other hand, we need to deliver a product that is as expected.

The name of the game is to generate repeat business. Customers return to get more of what they enjoyed the first time. If they don’t get that, then they could just as well have gone somewhere else.

Just think back for a moment about how many times in your life you had a great experience somewhere, and then went back only to find that what you had last time was not what you got the next time. Did you go back a third time just to make sure?

Probably not.

Where do you go frequently? Most probably to a place that is very consistent in some aspect of their service delivery that is important to you. That consistency is what brings you back.

Requiring consistency in the delivery process is universal across all types of services. It is the foundation of your success, and that applies to all service businesses, the way your insurance company processes your claim, the way the consultant interacts with you, how your auditing firm performs the audit. You return to the same supplier in all of these situations because you liked the way he or she did the work.

Together with emotions, consistency is an important element in our ability to recall one service experience more easily than others. You remember the consistently good experiences. They stand out. You have a much harder time remembering inconsistent experiences because you easily confuse them with all of the other inconsistent experiences that you have had.

Customers come back to experiences that consistently live up to their expectations. When that happens, we call it loyalty. Loyalty is built on consistency. Never forget that.

So take a good hard look at your basic processes, are they consistent?

This blog post is part of a series of answers to frequent questions that I get around the concept of the Service Profit Chain. In future’s posts, we will continue to explore other key points. If you would like the full concept served up in one go, you will find Mike’s book “Best! No need to be cheap if…” HERE.

How does one design a great experience?

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Positive Experience We talk a lot about the customer experience. We even talk about an experience economy. But what do we actually mean, and when can we qualify something as an experience?

Firstly, let be clear. Everything is an experience. Unless we have managed to shut down every sensor in our system, we will be experiencing something. The challenge is that experiences come in three broad categories: God, bad and indifferent. Most of your experiences belong to the last category – indifferent. If I ask you ‘So how was your train commute this morning compared to the same Monday last year?’, you would probably give me a rather blank stare.

This Monday last year? Sorry, I can’t remember at all what that was like.

Why not? Because the experience was bland, it was no different from all your other morning commutes. To put in very simple terms, there was no emotional trigger.

What makes us remember one experience and not the other depends on to what degree our emotions were stirred. Remember your first teenage date? Most of us do. Or the birth of your first child? The stronger the emotion, positive or negative, the more the experience is etched into our memory.

So most of our experiences are quickly forgotten. There is no emotional trigger. What we retain are the negative and the positive experiences.

So what do we mean by positive and negative in this context? Do I need to bring in a 12 man Mariachi band for this wedding party to be successful or would a 3 piece Jazz trio work just as well or better?

It’s not about the ‘thing’.

It’s about the customer and their perception of what is going on. You see, what causes a shift in our emotional makeup is tied to shifts in the circumstances that we happen to be in. When circumstances change to the better (compared to what we expected), then we are slightly happier; if they shift to something much better than we expected, we are very happy. On the other hand, if they shift to something worse than we expected, we are miserable. And if everything is running exactly as we thought it would, we are … indifferent.

Once we understand this, we have a great design tool at our disposal. We need to work on managing expectations. So standing in a queue at the airport security for 10 long minutes is hell on earth if you thought you would be through in a breeze; but it’s actually not too bad if there is a sign that says from this point on just 10 more minutes, and if we then get through in 8 minutes is actually a good experience.

In most types of customer journeys, there will be things that need to happen that may not be easy to frame as positive. Queuing is one, having a tooth fixed at the dentist might be another. It is not always possible to turn negative experiences into something positive but we can often neutralise them by putting the customer more in control, helping them set their expectations. So my dentist will say ‘In a moment I am going to do this. It might be a bit painful but it’s quick and you will feel much better afterward.’ Now I know what to expect. Ouch! It happens exactly as she said, so no shift in my emotions. Then she finishes up and we have a little chat about my last vacation and what I plan to do next weekend. She is such a nice lady. And there you go. The negative aspect was neutralised and she ended on a positive note making a personal connection: Man I just love going to the dentist.

So if you want to design a great experience, you need first to map out the customer journey, touch points by touch points. Then you make a note, for this type of customer persona, would this be considered positive, neutral or negative? Then, make a plan to eliminate or neutralise the negatives, upgrade a few of the neutrals to positive and make sure that whatever else happens, you end the experience on a positive note. Nothing affects our emotional state as much as the way things end. A movie that ends on an unhappy note is rarely a success. It just doesn’t work.

And finally, what is the one thing we can always do that consistently exceeds our customers’ expectations at any touch point? Be nice and make a personal connection. It blows them away.

What is the difference between satisfaction and loyalty?

April 14, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Loyalty and Satisfaction

In a world of abundance, too much of everything, what we also sometimes describe as hyper-competition, understanding the difference between satisfaction and loyalty is also the key to profits and growth.

There are many different ways of defining loyalty out there but this is my favourite one (not one invented but I can’t for the life of me remember where I found it): A loyal customer is someone who is willing to pay a bit more for your service than they would have to pay somewhere else for a similar experience.

Think about that for a moment…

If they are paying the same price to you as they would pay anywhere else, they are not loyal. It is just convenient for them to do business with you. And if they are paying less, you have just bribed them to stay with you.

So there you have it, satisfaction is manly about avoiding dissatisfaction: Delivering on the primary results in a consistent and reliable way, what Tom Peters so famously called Ho-Hum.

There is no loyalty in satisfaction. It is just Ho-Hum.

Loyalty is about a connection. Loyalty is emotional, not rational. Loyalty is Wow! You have this ‘feeling’ about a place, a product.

Just think about all the stuff that you own. Of all the things in your possession, which ones are in your eyes brands and what are just products?

It’s quite simple: A product or service becomes a brand when you have a feeling for it.

And then we are back full circle to the Service Profit Chain because things do not create emotions, people do. When I think of a certain hotel or café that I am very fond of, it’s the people. They have some people who have made an effort and established a connection with me, and yes I will gladly pay a premium for that emotional connection. It makes my day.

This blog post is part of a series of answers to frequent questions that I get around the concept of the Service Profit Chain. In future post, we will continue to explore other key points. If you would like the full concept served up in one go, you will find Mike’s book “Best! No need to be cheap if…” HERE.

What is value to a customer?

August 17, 2020By Mike Hohnen

Or, Why Value Is Not about Money.

In the old economy, the one dominated by goods, value was created through the transfer of ownership. I create or produce something; and when I transfer the ownership to you, you give me money in return. The way you check the value of what you bought has to do with the specifications. Whether you are looking for strawberries or a new car, it is about product attributes. This ‘widget’ is _______ (stronger, faster, slimmer, tastier…) than the other ones you have looked at.

In the new economy, the service economy, value is created in use.
When I rent a car, use a consultant, or search for a great place to stay for my vacation, there is no transfer of ownership. It is all about utility – I need something, and my preferred service is the one that best takes care of that need. When my need is met, it translates into a result for me. And most of us are more than happy to pay for getting the result we need.

So, if our aim is to create a great customer service experience, the starting point is to make sure that what we are offering matches the value expectation of the customer.

In order to do that, we use the Value Equation – a tool that originates from the research conducted to produce the Service Profit Chain framework. The Value Equation has four elements:

R Is for Result.

What is the result that the client is expecting or looking for? Do we understand the need? If I buy an airline ticket from Paris to Rome, and we end up in Berlin, the airline did not deliver the result that I was expecting. So, no matter how cheap the ticket is or how many drinks they serve, it is a lousy service experience. Do you book a table in a restaurant because you are hungry? Maybe. More often, you have a different need. Maybe you are looking for a special moment, an occasion to celebrate or an ideal setting for a special conversation. Whatever it is, the food is just an instrument in providing the real result that you are looking for.

This means that for every service product we create, we need to ask ourselves, “What is the result they are looking for?”

P Is for Process.
You can fly from A to B with many different airlines. In general, they will all get you to where you planned to go; but each one does it their way. The difference comes out in their process.

From a customer’s point-of-view, process has five elements. Each plays a part when evaluating to what extent the value proposition actually covered their needs.

Time: How does time play into the need or result that they have? Is it important that we are on time? Is it important that we are fast or slow? If my wife and I are having dinner before the cinema, we are looking for one kind of time experience. If we are celebrating her birthday the following week, we are looking for a different kind of time experience. Same people, same restaurant, but different situations.

Reliability: Do we do what we say we will do? Are we consistent?

Competence: How does the customer experience the competence level of our employee at a given touch point? How well do our frontline teams respond when asked a question or a request for help?

Empathy: To what extent are our employees able to see the situation from the client’s point-of-view? When a customer feels understood, we are more than halfway to solving their needs.

Proof of service: Do we provide a service that the client does not notice? Are there ways that we could remind the client that we are servicing them?

Under the fraction line we have:
$ for price and E for effort: The client pays a price for our service; but depending on the service package, they also put in more or less effort themselves. If you buy a sofa from IKEA, the price is low; but you put in quite a bit of effort yourself. If you fly Virgin Upper Class, they will pick you up at your office and take you and your stuff right to the plane; A different experience than flying Ryanair, and, to be fair, also at a different price point.

So, there you have it.
If you want to understand how customers perceive value, the value equation is your key. And, your starting point for developing a great customer experience is to understand how you tailor your customer value proposition to each segment using the Value Equation.

I would be happy to send you a copy of the Value equation at a glance – just fill in your email below.

Why the Service Profit Chain concept is more important now than ever before?

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Service Business

Check out Google trends, the interest in customer service and customer experience is steadily rising year by year and has been for the past 5 years.

Why?

Because we live in an age of abundance – this is one of my key points when I give live presentations. By abundance I mean that there is too much of everything. There are more hotel rooms, restaurant seats, cars for hire or consultants etc. than the market actually needs. So we are all trying to survive in a hyper-competitive environment.

In a hyper-competitive environment, it is not enough to try and compete on product specifications. Because within a given price bracket, the specifications for most product are more or less identical. So in order to differentiate, we need to look at the experience and that typically means that we add some service components.

On top of that, we are rapidly moving away from products and into services (Just think cars, in a few years when cars become self driving, they will no longer be products but we will see them as a service). So society is moving to service dominant logic. And when products are turned into services, the focus shifts, it is not about the product spec but the customer need.

If we want to compete on experience and service, we need to focus on the interaction between the frontline staff and the guest/customer – what we also call the touch points. That is the critical interface – that interaction can lift what is otherwise just a bland run of the mill experience into a memorable experience. And when that happens, we create loyalty. High customer loyalty is the key profits a growth.

So some companies launch major initiatives around creating loyalty. They see that as their main objective.

But that is only because they are not paying attention to the principles of the Service Profit Chain – in a sense they have got the wrong end of the stick.

There is no shortcut to the profits and growth. You need to take the long haul and that starts with creating an inspiring and engaging workplace, and that is what the concept of the Service Profit Chain can help you do – and that is why understanding this key framework is the best way to survive in a hyper competitive environment.

Check our my course The Service Profit Chain explained!

_________________________________________________

Why my fear of roller coasters does not keep me out of amusement parks

April 13, 2022By Mike Hohnen

Helix - Liseberg - Gothenburg — *Helix – Liseberg – Gothenburg*

They scare the living daylight out of me those roller coasters.

Intellectually I understand that they are safe, probably safer that taking a taxi to the airport, statistically… but still. It’s always been like that, so maybe in a previous life I was traumatised by a roller coaster gone wild. Anyway that is not the point of this final blog post of the year. The reason I mention it is because paradoxically this year I have seen more incredible roller coasters and heard more delighted shrieks from thrilled crowds than at any time previously in my life. More on that in just a minute.

Yes I am in a reflective mood.

You see, technically, this week is just like all the other weeks, but somehow in our mind it’s quite special. It marks an ending and a new beginning and we all get in this mood of yearly review and even more importantly setting new bold goals for the coming year.

All my lovely blogging colleagues are probably bombarding you with: The ten best books you should have read, the eight new trends that you must understand or (flavour of the year) the twelve point action plan that will make this your best year ever!

So why the roller coasters?

Well believe it or not, this was the year that I got to spend considerable time in amusements parks!

Seriously!

As always I have been doing work with my loyal gang of regular hotel clients, but I also got to spend time at Efteling in Holland introducing the Service Profit Chain for IAAPA. In Copenhagen, we introduced a new approach to leadership development at Tivoli gardens and I had the honour for 16 weeks to take a group of seriously enthusiastic managers from Liseberg in Gothenburg through the GROW leadership program.

So what am I learning?

I think my key takeaway this year has been confirmation that at the end of the day, being a great manager is deceptively simple on the surface, and incredibly hard to do well in practice. It’s like juggling. You see the guy rotating 5 oranges in the air and you think: “That’s neat. I can do that.” You pick up the oranges and you understand that there is a gap between knowing and doing.

The 5 oranges of management that you need to juggle have been elegantly formulated by the Gallup organisation based on their extensive research of hundreds of business and managers.

Great managers have these talents/skills/abilities:

They motivate every single employee to take action and engage them with a compelling mission and vision.
They have the assertiveness to drive outcomes and the ability to overcome adversity and resistance.
They create a culture of clear accountability.
They build relationships that create trust, open dialogue, and full transparency.
They make decisions that are based on productivity, not politics.

That’s it! But again this is just more information, and I am sure you don’t need more information.

What you need is probably execution, the HOW part.

So that brings me to next year. Early 2017, we will be launched the Team Leader’s Toolbox – a training program aimed at helping busy mangers learn quickly how they juggle their ‘oranges’.

We have been exploring this theme of Leadership and Management over the year on the blog as well and if you missed some of the posts you can download a compilation in the form of ebook HERE.

Thank you for reading my blog. If there is anything you would like to see more (or less) of next year, don’t hesitate to drop me a line. I love hearing from my readers.

_________________________________________________

This post is one of a series where we are exploring the notion of leadership and how this is different from management. Our starting point is the Service Profit Chain and the understating that the management part of our job will only take us so far. If we really want to create an organisation that is capable of delivering outstanding customer experiences, we need to develop an organisation that delivers outstanding employee experiences – and that requires leadership. You can check out other articles of the series below:

The something for something system is at the heart of the uninspiring workplace.

October 29, 2016By Mike Hohnen

Unspiring

The Something-For-Something System is what happens in most organizations today.

Here is how it works. You come into work and give some of your time in return for a salary. If you work a bit harder, or a little bit more, or a little bit better, you have an expectation that you will also be rewarded for it — a bonus, overtime pay, a promotion, or whatever.

If you don’t work so hard or don’t do your job very well, it is built into the model that you can expect some kind of ‘punishment’.

The assumption is that you come to work because it is in your own interest. You need the money so you can pay your rent, feed the kids, or play golf during the weekend. It’s a something-for-something kind of thinking which has thousands of years behind it. Technically, it is known as transactional leadership.

The Game We Play

If the employer and the employee, or in practical terms, the manager and the employee, have a relationship which basically is about something-for-something, then it very easily becomes a game where you, as an employee, try to get away with doing as little as possible while at the same time getting the maximum amount out.

In that perspective, you could say that from the employee’s perspective, you have actually won something if you managed to do a little bit less and still get paid the same for it. That would be a win for you.

The manager’s role in an organization that practices transactional leadership is not very exiting either, because what this means is that the manager’s most important role is to control whether or not the organization is actually getting the output that the organization is paying for. That means time-stamping, control sheets, registration, serious conversations, the possibility of written warnings, and eventually, the ultimate punishment – layoffs.

In a transactional world, an effective manager is a person who distributes reward and punishment in such a way that he maximizes the output of the employee.

It’s all about management and there is no time for real leadership.

Management by Exception

In a transactional world, the manager manages by exception. By that, I mean that the manager is actually only exercising their management role when something is not working according to the plan, not living up to the expectations. Only when somebody’s not doing what they’re supposed to be doing, they put on their managers cap and do something… maybe.

Maybe, because as most of us don’t actually enjoy being bossy. As a result, the management role easily turns into non-management – something I only do if I absolutely must.

If things are going sort of reasonably OK, then there’s no real reason to do much, is there? It becomes a sort of ‘let sleeping dogs lie’ atmosphere. And in the organizations that are really bad, the supervisor, who is supposed to manage his front-line, gets this same treatment from his department head, who gets exactly the same laissez-faire management from the division VP or whatever. The something-for-something culture runs all the way through the system.

Unfortunately, a lot of research shows that this leadership style is neither inspiring nor the most productive. It’s not something that creates an extraordinary organization or fantastically enthusiastic and loyal customers.

It produces something that is often okay, but rarely fantastic.

It’s built into the model that it has to be like that; it is all that can happen as long as we have that mindset.

Now, I hope you are beginning to see what the problem is.

As long as we understand the world from a transactional paradigm, the something-for-something mindset, we aren’t going to get any further. We are stuck.

So, what is it going to take?

Well, as Frederic Laloux says, we need to move into a completely different mindset. We need to change our paradigm. We need to switch from transactional leadership to transformational leadership.

___________________________________________________

A Managers Guide to a Dream Team

April 14, 2022By Mike Hohnen

The Service Profit Chain is a well-documented concept.

Since the original research was published in 1989, hundreds of articles have promoted the original findings which essentially boil down to the fact that happy employees create happy customers – and the happier the customers you have, the more money you make –
Yes, I know that was a very simplified version.

What not so many people talk about, or even document, is that this concept of ‘happy employees’ is not so much a question of employee satisfaction but, to a much higher degree, a question of employee engagement.
So, what are the steps to producing a high level of engagement on a service team?
According to the original research in The Service Profit Chain, there 8 steps in a self-reinforcing cycle called the dream team cycle.
Look closely and you will recognize that this is exactly what the best high profile service companies do:

The Right Team
Careful selection of new recruits. Hire for attitude. Train for skills.Coach for performance and that includes dealing with the bad apples.
Continuous Improvement
Best in class training and development at all levels in the organization. Continuous improvement is considered one of the great benefits of the job. “In this job, I grow”…
Great Support Systems
Service is not just something the frontline does for our customers. Service is our culture. Employees and managers who do not have customer contact service the employees that do. (Our IT department is not the IT-Police – it is an internal service department that supports the frontline in getting the job done.)
Empowerment
The best service employees take pride in solving the problem on the spot. So the freedom to act is hugely motivating. Southwest Airlines famously tells its employees, ”You may do anything you are not uncomfortable doing to solve a passengers problem.”
Clear Expectations
In the same way that anyone who has made it to a great sports team knows what is expected of them, employees in the best service organizations also know what is expected of them. It is part of their motivation to be part of a team that is not afraid to set the bar high.
Appropriate Rewards and Recognition
Focusing on what works, celebrating success, and acknowledging each others contributions makes work meaningful.
High Levels of Satisfaction and Engagement
As a result of Steps 1-6, we generate not just higher levels of satisfaction, but also real engagement – Service work becomes fun and meaningful.

Employees Recommend New Employees
When we need to recruit new team members, our best employees recommend friends and previous colleagues from other organizations because these are the people they would like to work with. Gradually we become the preferred employer in our region – which means we get the pick of the crop.

And that takes us back to Step 1 – The Right Team.
Done consistently this 8-step cycle become a self-reinforcing process that propels our service delivery capacity to higher and higher levels – and we all know what that does for our customer satisfaction and loyalty.

——

Building a great service business begins with understanding the Service Profit Chain framework. In my view, that is the foundation. Check out my free introduction here